Send them back? I don't really know but for $1K I would definitely expect them to fit. Did you specify your car was a '96 when ordering? I believe the VMania, and probably others, are unique for that year due to the additional weather stipping added by Dodge for the facotry Mopar sliding windows. Please post up how you resolve this. I've been considering picking up a set of VMania windows for my '96, but have been concerned about the fit, especially with the factory hard top.
Contact me at 703-960-6682 and we'll fix the problem... There is a an adjustment that I make prior to shipping if the windows are to be used with a Mopar top, it seems as though this wasn't done on your set. I agree for 1K "They should Fit!!"....Thanks!!