Go Back   Viper Alley - Dodge Viper Forum » Back Alley » Anything Goes
» Live Feed « · War Room · Graffiti Wall · Chat · Arcade · Viper Blogs · » Viper Tube «

Anything Goes Well, almost anything. Bring your A game or be sent home.

       

Motion to put ip addresses on every post

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes

Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:08 PM   #1
Senior Member
 
vipernathan's Avatar
 
vipernathan is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,960
vipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 points
Rep Power: 9
Motion to put ip addresses on every post

A few think it may be a good idea to post a user's ip address as a way to create consistancy among posters and eliminate people from posting irresponsible messages. I peronally would like a equal playing field where everybody knows as much as everybody else, so far that is not the case and is causing some trust issues on my side. How is this site different than .com is what I keep asking myself.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:10 PM   #2
Senior Member
 
Captain Bli is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,363
Captain Bli is well liked with 163 pointsCaptain Bli is well liked with 163 points
Rep Power: 9
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

NO, NO ,NO.
Motion denied.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:11 PM   #3
Senior Member
 
vipernathan's Avatar
 
vipernathan is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,960
vipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 points
Rep Power: 9
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

Why not ? What is the harm here?
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:11 PM   #4
Tonight We Dine In Hell!
 
packetjunkie's Avatar
 
packetjunkie is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Virginia
Posts: 20,170
packetjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 points
Rep Power: 28
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

.com had no moderation and no way for anyone to know who was who (well, until I wrote Troll Tracker, that is).

Here we have the power to elect people to represent the sites best interests and monitor Trolls without overbearing moderation.

In the 7,000+ posts made I think 1 or 2 have been deleted, but we have successfully avoided a Troll problem that plagued DotCom.

I would not support the posting of everyone's IP address. However, there should be ways for people to get information under certain circumstances.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:12 PM   #5
Senior Member
 
Toby is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,504
Toby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 pointsToby is The Man with 1662 points
Rep Power: 25
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

I agree that IP address should be shown with each post. Other message boards do it and it seems to work well. If anyone needs an example please refer to this message board...

http://www.clubcobra.com/

then go to the forum section.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:13 PM   #6
Schadenfreude Connoisseur
 
Smokin's Avatar
 
Smokin is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 13,149
Smokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 points
Rep Power: 19
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

I will be the first to say that many will STOP POSTING AND QUIT THE BOARD if their IP address is available for all to see. DONT BE STUPID. Just like many dont want their home addresses on here.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:15 PM   #7
Senior Member
 
vipernathan's Avatar
 
vipernathan is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,960
vipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 points
Rep Power: 9
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

PJ -

The fact of the matter is, we want a equal playing field. Plain and simple. People should be responsible for what they say at all times. Funny AE's are different and who cares if we know who the AE is. Jamit is still funny and we know who he is.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:15 PM   #8
par
Senior Member
 
par's Avatar
 
par is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 4,814
par is unremarkable with 10 points
Rep Power: 0
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

The difference between this site and others is that you get to control how it operates through a democratic system. It's not perfect, but we think it's better than anything else out there. This site is for the members.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:16 PM   #9
Senior Member
 
King GTS's Avatar
 
King GTS is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 15,070
King GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 points
Rep Power: 29
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

[quote=vipernathan] PJ -

The fact of the matter is, we want a equal playing field. Plain and simple. People should be responsible for what they say at all times. Funny AE's are different and who cares if we know who the AE is. Jamit is still funny and we know who he is. <hr /></blockquote>

Who is he! We know that guy?
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:16 PM   #10
Schadenfreude Connoisseur
 
Smokin's Avatar
 
Smokin is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 13,149
Smokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 pointsSmokin made Varsity with 1140 points
Rep Power: 19
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

Vipernathan, why do you think we are here to get you? Do you know how many times I got banned at the morgue for speaking up for good representation? Are you telling us that you think we are here to smoosh your free speech? Why dont you trust us? If you want me gone as a moderator go request a fucking poll. I have spent hours contributing to this site and getting people to come here. Some of this latest bullshit has got to stop. THERE IS NO PERFECT SYSTEM. STOP TRYING TO CREATE IT! FUCKING GODDAMN LIBERAL REACTIONS TO EVERY FUCKING THING.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:16 PM   #11
Senior Member
 
vipernathan's Avatar
 
vipernathan is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,960
vipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 points
Rep Power: 9
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

How is it dangerous? (maybe I'm ignorant to this, but shead some light)
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:17 PM   #12
Mexican Frogger
 
Jeff M's Avatar
 
Jeff M is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: San Antonio aka Northern Mexico
Posts: 9,210
Jeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 pointsJeff M is The Man with 1968 points
Rep Power: 23
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

[quote=King GTS] [quote=vipernathan] PJ -

The fact of the matter is, we want a equal playing field. Plain and simple. People should be responsible for what they say at all times. Funny AE's are different and who cares if we know who the AE is. Jamit is still funny and we know who he is. <hr /></blockquote>

Who is he! We know that guy? <hr /></blockquote>


  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:19 PM   #13
Tonight We Dine In Hell!
 
packetjunkie's Avatar
 
packetjunkie is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Virginia
Posts: 20,170
packetjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 pointspacketjunkie is The Man with 1829 points
Rep Power: 28
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

I think if you take a poll, you will find the majority of people disagree. But put it to a vote - whatever the guidelines are for doing that.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:19 PM   #14
Senior Member
 
vipernathan's Avatar
 
vipernathan is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,960
vipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 points
Rep Power: 9
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

Didn't Eric say he was Jamit? Smoke, I'll reply to you in one sec.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:22 PM   #15
par
Senior Member
 
par's Avatar
 
par is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 4,814
par is unremarkable with 10 points
Rep Power: 0
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

I will bow to what the majority wants, if that is showing IP's then that's what we should do. Let's have a poll on the topic.

Even though i am against showing IP's, as i think it defeats the purpose of an AE, and i think AE's bring value and humour to this site, i will do what the members decide. The price of democracy is that we sometimes has to do things we don't want to. Now if you this polls outcome is against showing the IP address i trust that you'll be fine with that Nathan?
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:23 PM   #16
You mean Shenanigans
 
Matt's Avatar
 
Matt is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 4,673
Matt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 pointsMatt is The Man with 1761 points
Rep Power: 19
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

I vote no.

It is dangerous if you use a static IP address.

If you don't, it won't serve any purpose anyhow because the poster's IP will change every time he dials up his service provider. So that completely circumvents the consistency you were looking for.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:24 PM   #17
Enthusiast
 
The Viperjudge is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 152
The Viperjudge is unremarkable with 10 points
Rep Power: 0
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

I would love to see IP addresses. It would make it easier to find out several people that I am looking for.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:25 PM   #18
TGM
n00b
 
TGM is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 15
TGM is unremarkable with 10 points
Rep Power: 0
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

Is serious eric jammit?
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:26 PM   #19
Senior Member
 
King GTS's Avatar
 
King GTS is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 15,070
King GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 pointsKing GTS is The Man with 2476 points
Rep Power: 29
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

[quote=Matt] I vote no.

It is dangerous if you use a static IP address.

If you don't, it won't serve any purpose anyhow because the poster's IP will change every time he dials up his service provider. So that completely circumvents the consistency you were looking for. <hr /></blockquote>

I agree. That's a good point.
  Reply With Quote

Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post
Old January 24th, 2003, 03:26 PM   #20
Senior Member
 
vipernathan's Avatar
 
vipernathan is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,960
vipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 pointsvipernathan is kissing alot of ass around here with 548 points
Rep Power: 9
Re: Motion to put ip addresses on every post

[quote=SmokinV10] Vipernathan, why do you think we are here to get you? Do you know how many times I got banned at the morgue for speaking up for good representation? Are you telling us that you think we are here to smoosh your free speech? Why dont you trust us? If you want me gone as a moderator go request a fucking poll. I have spent hours contributing to this site and getting people to come here. Some of this latest bullshit has got to stop. THERE IS NO PERFECT SYSTEM. STOP TRYING TO CREATE IT! FUCKING GODDAMN LIBERAL REACTIONS TO EVERY FUCKING THING. <hr /></blockquote>

I don't think you are here to get me. Why when I am talking directly to Pj, do you assume that I am talking to you? All I want here is to know what you know that's all. If you think this is unrealistic, well them let me be a moderator so I can be in the know. I realize that you have a lot invested and that's fine, but let's not say this is a equal playing field when there are people that have information that I don't. Never said there is a perfect system, I am just trying to make things better and if you don't agree, so be it. Where the fuck do you come off calling me a liberal? Because I don't conform to your opinion? Sorry, I am a individual, I hope some can appretiate that.

For the record, I have never, ever said I have a problem with any moderator, if you are going to try to debate, please do not put words into my mouth, it's not fair. I am trying to better this system and I don't want to have to clear things with anyone before I post, or before I request a poll.

one last thing, why do people try to make things personal? It's not the best strategy.
  Reply With Quote
Reply

  Viper Alley - Dodge Viper Forum » Back Alley » Anything Goes

«