Go Back   Viper Alley - Dodge Viper Forum » Back Alley » Anything Goes
» Live Feed « · War Room · Graffiti Wall · Chat · Arcade · Viper Blogs · » Viper Tube «

Anything Goes Well, almost anything. Bring your A game or be sent home.

       

British Soldiers, what do you think?

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes

British Soldiers, what do you think?
Old April 6th, 2007, 09:50 AM   #1
Casey
Senior Member
 
Casey is offline
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 1,908
Casey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 points
Rep Power: 11
British Soldiers, what do you think?

I watched the press conference this morning.

It would seem the worst treatment they received was Blindfolded and put in a 8x6 cell. No doubt this would be a bit stressful, but enough to make them act the way they did? You've got to be kidding me.

The one soldier said that If they tried to talk to their friend, they were told to "Shhh".

No sleep deprevation, 3 meals a day, all the water they wanted, allowed to smoke, and gift bags to bring home, while wearing fresh suits.

Sounds like an add for "Vacation Iran"
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 10:12 AM   #2
Leaf001
Senior Member
 
Leaf001's Avatar
 
Leaf001 is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Jacksonville, Fl
Posts: 4,039
Leaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 points
Rep Power: 16
If that is true, then they are in violation of several articles on the UCMJ (if they were American servicemen). We are required to memorize exactley what to say and do if captured.

Granted, these are not aviators or special forces, but I'm sure they received similar training going through basic.

I don't know the entire situation, nor am I privy to the debriefing transcripts, but from an outside perspective it appears as though they are accontable under several charges (if they were American servicemen).

I'm not calling them cowards for dishonoring themselves, their unit, and their country....but
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 11:15 AM   #3
Doc
Vtec Yo
 
Doc's Avatar
 
Doc is offline
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 2,466
Doc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 points
Rep Power: 17
A good portion were Royal Marines, I would have expected more from them. Further, I never quite understood how they were captured in the first place as they were in a pair of fast patrol boats that should have been able to turn tail as they saw 6 Iranian vessels rapidly approaching.

With carrier presence in the gulf we could have had air support there in minutes.

I guess they never covered Name, Rank and Serial Number in England. I guess they skip seer training as well (Survival, Evasion, Escape, Resistance Training).
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 11:27 AM   #4
Leaf001
Senior Member
 
Leaf001's Avatar
 
Leaf001 is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Jacksonville, Fl
Posts: 4,039
Leaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 points
Rep Power: 16
Basic grunts don't receive SERE training. The students who attend this Navy course are the ones who have a greater risk of being stranded behind enemy lines, such as aviators, aircrewmen, Special Forces and force reconnaissance personnel.

The ROE only permit open fire as a retalitory measure. It's complete BS, but as a member of my last command's NCB VBSS team, this is what the standing orders were.
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 11:30 AM   #5
Leaf001
Senior Member
 
Leaf001's Avatar
 
Leaf001 is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Jacksonville, Fl
Posts: 4,039
Leaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 points
Rep Power: 16
I guess this says something about the British Royal Marines ....every Devil Dog I've served with would be taking heads before letting himself be captured.
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 11:31 AM   #6
HighRoller
Eccentric
 
HighRoller's Avatar
 
HighRoller is offline
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 4,228
HighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 pointsHighRoller is The Man with 1590 points
Rep Power: 17
Strong opinions based on incomplete facts and speculation.

WAR ARMCHAIR QUARTERBACKS
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 11:36 AM   #7
Mark O
Senior Member
 
Mark O's Avatar
 
Mark O is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 12,385
Mark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 pointsMark O is The Man with 1654 points
Rep Power: 23
The crew was flown home. Where's the ship?
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 11:47 AM   #8
Doc
Vtec Yo
 
Doc's Avatar
 
Doc is offline
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 2,466
Doc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 pointsDoc is The Man with 1886 points
Rep Power: 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by HighRoller View Post
Strong opinions based on incomplete facts and speculation.

WAR ARMCHAIR QUARTERBACKS

Hi, this is the alley. Have you been here before?
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 05:49 PM   #9
radta7
1997 B/W GTS
 
radta7's Avatar
 
radta7 is offline
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: NW burbs of Chicago
Posts: 1,737
radta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 pointsradta7 is The Man with 1545 points
Rep Power: 14
I am sure their treatment was worse than released....so far. I cannot understand how they could follow through with the Iranian demands so soon. Highroller does have an excellent point.
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 06:18 PM   #10
banton
Senior Member
 
banton's Avatar
 
banton is offline
Join Date: Nov 2005
Posts: 1,919
banton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 pointsbanton is The Man with 1790 points
Rep Power: 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leaf001 View Post
I guess this says something about the British Royal Marines ....every Devil Dog I've served with would be taking heads before letting himself be captured.
Maybe they were trained by the French.

WAR SURRENDER!
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 06:59 PM   #11
SoCal Rebell
Road Racer
 
SoCal Rebell's Avatar
 
SoCal Rebell is offline
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Mission Hills
Posts: 18,430
SoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 pointsSoCal Rebell is not afraid of bears with 2565 points
Rep Power: 31
Quote:
Originally Posted by HighRoller View Post
Strong opinions based on incomplete facts and speculation.

WAR ARMCHAIR QUARTERBACKS
True Neil and I agree 100%, the only thing that peeved me was some of them got off the jet with the "goodie bags" Iran gave them.

.
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 07:17 PM   #12
vip gts
Enthusiast
 
vip gts is offline
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 111
vip gts is a B-Teamer with 81 points
Rep Power: 2
Some of these soldiers were interviewed prior to their capture several months ago and stated that their mission was surveillance of the Iranians. I think the Iranians have some info that would be embarrassing for Britain and this gave them leverage.
  Reply With Quote

Old April 6th, 2007, 08:58 PM   #13
Richie-SRT10
MuscleCar Nut
 
Richie-SRT10's Avatar
 
Richie-SRT10 is offline
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Crystal River, Fl.
Posts: 5,760
Richie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 points
Rep Power: 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by banton View Post
Maybe they were trained by the French.

WAR SURRENDER!


You have to give the French credit for having the experience to welcome invading armies for several hundred years & turning over the keys to Paris on a frequent basis



Fly this or you aint flying shit!!!
  Reply With Quote

Old April 7th, 2007, 10:04 AM   #14
Casey
Senior Member
 
Casey is offline
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 1,908
Casey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 points
Rep Power: 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by HighRoller View Post
Strong opinions based on incomplete facts and speculation.

WAR ARMCHAIR QUARTERBACKS

Opinions based on the soldiers accounts of what happened to them, during a live interview/press conference.

WAR WHITE FLAG
  Reply With Quote

Old April 7th, 2007, 10:05 AM   #15
Casey
Senior Member
 
Casey is offline
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 1,908
Casey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 pointsCasey made Varsity with 873 points
Rep Power: 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by SoCal Rebell View Post
True Neil and I agree 100%, the only thing that peeved me was some of them got off the jet with the "goodie bags" Iran gave them.

.
Did you notice their new suits they were wearing while handling those "goodie bags"?
  Reply With Quote

Old April 7th, 2007, 04:39 PM   #16
Richie-SRT10
MuscleCar Nut
 
Richie-SRT10's Avatar
 
Richie-SRT10 is offline
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Crystal River, Fl.
Posts: 5,760
Richie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 pointsRichie-SRT10 is The Man with 2303 points
Rep Power: 20
What is wrong with a little gift bag filled with some hash and Tony Blair Bobblehead.
  Reply With Quote

Old April 7th, 2007, 05:57 PM   #17
Leaf001
Senior Member
 
Leaf001's Avatar
 
Leaf001 is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Jacksonville, Fl
Posts: 4,039
Leaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 pointsLeaf001 made Varsity with 1213 points
Rep Power: 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by Casey View Post
Opinions based on the soldiers accounts of what happened to them, during a live interview/press conference.

WAR WHITE FLAG
Thank you.
  Reply With Quote

Old April 8th, 2007, 05:47 PM   #18
GTS Bruce
Senior Member
 
GTS Bruce is offline
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 570
GTS Bruce is well liked with 199 pointsGTS Bruce is well liked with 199 points
Rep Power: 7
Its over for England and the english.They have gone french(gay).Probably sell the goody bags and suits on e-bay. Then again our elected leaders are bending us over to prep us to be annexed by Mexico. GTS Bruce
  Reply With Quote